Law Offices of Connie Yi, PC - estate planning
Tell Us About Your Case

For the safety of our community, clients and staff, we have suspended all in-person meeting effective March 17, 2020. All consultation meetings will be via Phone or Zoom Video Conferencing. Please contact us at 925-484-0888 or email us directly at [email protected] to schedule the consultation.

Bay Area Estate And Tax Planning Law Firm
Estate Planning
Trust Administration and probate

Clerical error does not invalidate wills, court says

| Jan 23, 2014 | Uncategorized |

Married couples who have begun the estate planning process probably already know that it is common to create complimentary wills with one’s spouse. Some people choose to create joint wills or wills that take the other’s plans into account, while others choose to keep their last will and testament confidential and separate from their spouse. There is no one right way to complete this process, it is up to the individuals to determine what makes the most sense for them.

In one recent case of a couple who created identical wills, a mistake in the execution process led to a conflict in court. The identical wills were apparently switched during the singing and witnessing process and each spouse accidentally signed the other’s will. This became an issue after the second of the two spouses passed away in 2006 and the wills were closely examined.

Upon inspection, it became clear that the wills had not been signed by the correct person as a result of a mistake by the lawyer who assisted them. The couple’s two sons argued that the wills should be disregarded and that their property should pass by default laws (called the laws of intestate succession). However, a third party argued that they should not be thrown out. The third party was a man who had a close relationship with the couple and had been referred to as one of their “sons” but who was not related to them by law. The couple had left him a substantial bequest in their wills.

After review by a court, the judge found that the documents did have a major error but that they should not be defeated on that reason alone but instead interpreted as though the error had not occurred. This case took place in the United Kingdom but it is likely that the outcome would be similar in the United States, since most courts will look at a clerical error and assume the most reasonable re-interpretation.

Source: Daily Mail, “Man wins legal fight over £70,000 inheritance as Supreme Court agrees there was a ‘clerical error’ in the will,” Jan. 22, 2014. 

Archives

FindLaw Network

Recent Blog Post

Even a fortune can disappear without sound estate planning

Some figures baffle.Like the speed of light. Like the age and size of the universe. And like estimates pegging the personal fortunes of America's richest families.Consider this imagery relevant to the storied Vanderbilt family for a moment: a pile of money equaling...

Remarrying couples unquestionably need to focus on estate planning

Many remarrying California individuals fail to timely consider and update existing estate plans to reflect new realities.Don't be one of them. Many remarrying California individuals fail to timely consider and update existing estate plans to reflect new...

View More Blog Posts